Explaining this may be a complicated matter, but Nosek has put forth a pretty decent theory. He believes that a lower cognitive capacity makes people more attracted to simplifying ideologies. On the surface it certainly seems to make sense. Some of the findings by Brock University are quantified in the chart plotting mean adolescent intelligence against adult political ideology.
 |
| IQ vs Political Orientation |
Now a professor from the University of Arkansas has echoed these sentiments, albeit in a slightly different study. This study, published in the journal "Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin", focused it's efforts on what is described as "low-effort" thinking. According to Dr. Scott Eidelman, the study's lead author, "People endorse conservative ideology more when they have to give a first or fast response." Eidelman cautions that while low-effort thinking promotes political conservatism it may not be the case that political conservatism necessarily promotes low-effort thinking.
The interesting part of these studies isn't that a relationship between IQ and political orientation exists, but why it exists. The answer to that conundrum awaits further studies.
This is a well-written, thought-provoking post! I'm anxious to see what further study reveals. Thank you for sharing, Penguin.
ReplyDeleteAs I do not accept free will I think a biological basis will be found for all human behaviors, including political orientation. The studies cited show correlation, but the detailed mechanism remains to be elucidated. The larger question, assuming this correlation holds up, is what do we as a society make of it? Good job Penguin.
ReplyDeleteGreat article, Penguin. Keep them coming.
ReplyDeleteThe only problem with comparing bell curves is that the average person doesn't grasp the significance of the overlap. I suggest not underestimating the intelligence of any particular individual conservative on the basis of these results (which certainly feel right!)
ReplyDeleteIntelligence has many dimensions. No one number, like IQ, can capture the whole picture. In any case correlation does not imply causality. I suspect there are many confounding factors involved in political preference including the preferred method of decision making. Those, like scientists, who generally prefer fact-based logical reasoning are far more liberal than the average American, more so perhaps than can be explained by IQ alone. See: http://www.panderingpoliticians.com/2011/08/scientists-have-liberal-bias.html
DeleteCan you cite the actual studies? Thanks.
ReplyDeleteJust do a search on the sources cited in the article and you will find many references. Access to the original studies published in refereed journals generally require paying actual money. A more recent study published in the March issue of the peer-reviewed Social Psychology Quarterly showed that liberals, atheists, and the monogamous have higher IQ's. See http://inventorspot.com/articles/study_equates_higher_iq_liberal_atheist_and_monogamous_values_38259.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI doubt that I'll see this kind of data on Fox News anytime soon.
ReplyDelete