Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Obama vs Romney Truth-Telling

(See more recent data here: Obama vs Romney Truth-Telling - Part II)

Now that it is clear President Obama will be running for reelection against Mitt Romney, Panderbear decided it was time to directly compare the details of their statement truth ratings. Panderbear created the chart from statement ratings by PolitiFact.org.

Those who have been reading Liar! Liar! regularly know that while President Obama's Truth Quotient (TQ) is solidly in truth-telling territory, Mitt Romney's is comparable to those of pandering Congressional leaders, which is to say not so good.

But what about the actual percentages of statement ratings in each of PolitiFact.org's categories: True, Mostly True, Half True, Mostly False, False, and Pants on Fire? These are revealed in Panderbear's chart.

It is clear that President Obama easily bests Romney in the percentage of true and mostly true statements. It is even more clear that Romney has a special talent for making pants on fire statements. His rate of outrageously over the top false statements is 7 to 8 times that of the president. In the other categories the differences may not be statistically significant except possibly Romney's higher percentage of mostly false statements.

Most voters don't seem to care much whether politicians are telling the truth as long as they are saying what they want to hear. Truth-telling does matter to Panderbear and hopes that it does to you as well.

Obama vs Romney Truth Telling

submit to reddit Share on Tumblr

25 comments:

  1. Thanks for this information! It's maddening how the Republicans wrap themselves in the flag, mom, and apple pie--"family values" and all that jazz--yet lie through their teeth. You'd think that telling the truth would be a foundational value of decency.

    ReplyDelete
  2. How to lie with stats...

    Fox Headline: Romney "True" ~60%, but Obama "half true" or "false" ~55%..

    MSNBC Headline: Obama "True" ~70%, while Romeny is 70% "half true" or "false."....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sad, but true. That's why the news consumer should always adhere to the maxim Caveat Emptor.

      Delete
  3. I was directed to this site to see a comparison between Obama and Romney. I see your chart but do you have the examples of the statements made that are questionable? I question your stats on Obama as I felt he has not been truthful from the beginning when he said that he administration was going to be the most transparent and that ALL bills would be posted on the internet for 5 days before being voted on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The statement ratings all come from PolitiFact.com. Every statement rating provides sources and a rationale for the rating. You can judge for yourself whether their ratings are reasonable or off the mark. I agree greater transparency would be better. As for posting bills on the internet for 5 days before being voted on, that is up to Congress, not the president.

      Delete
  4. What do you think of selection bias?

    ReplyDelete
  5. It appears from the graph that the odds of Romney making a statement that is either "true" or "mostly true" is roughly 33%, or one in three.

    Probably not coincidentally, those are the same odds you get by playing the shell game of "guess where the pea is hidden".

    ReplyDelete
  6. Considering Obama Care is a tax, this administration is not transparent, Obama claims he visited 57 states, either lies about or can't remember his own birthday and refuses to provide non-altered documentation as proof of his citizenship I would have to say I will trust Romney first. Obama killed the Trans-Canada pipeline to get votes in November even though everyone in Congress on both sides said we needed it just like none of them would accept his budget. Trusting Obama will get you screwed but with Romney there is a chance however small that you will be okay.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do you really believe President Obama doesn't know how many states there are? The 'birther' issue was resolved conclusively by the state of Hawaii ages ago. It's a non-issue. Obama did not kill the Trans-Canada pipeline. He okayed part of it and required additional environment impact study of the rest. Your statement regarding "both sides said we needed it..." is just plain false.

      More generally Panderbear does not decide issues and who to vote for on the basis of trust, but based on fact-based logical reasoning and best science. Those are currently on the side of President Obama.

      Delete
  7. Truth matters and it is critical with the presidential role.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. obama news capread

    ReplyDelete
  9. its an amazing article i read! thanks to share us !
    Download Your favorite games and Softwares For Free. visit the links for download latets and update version of games, software. we offer you free full version games and software in one click download,

    Pc Software Free
    Pc Games Free
    Pc Software Free

    ReplyDelete
  10. HMA pro vpn license key 2020 android contains security protocols that protect all personal data without threats. It is also easy to use with one click; They are protected and it is a small package for each device, iOS, Android, and Windows. Because of its excellent performance, it should never interfere with operating systems. In addition, it is extremely secure and user data remains secure at all times.
    HMA Pro VPN License Key
    little alterboy vst crack
    clariphonic dsp for mac
    windows 10 crack

    ReplyDelete
  11. best way to recover your phone
    https://bit.ly/3pGTY7O
    https://bit.ly/3hA6rHw
    https://bit.ly/3rFS35j

    ReplyDelete
  12. best way to recover your phone
    https://bit.ly/3pGTY7O
    https://bit.ly/3hA6rHw
    https://bit.ly/3rFS35j

    ReplyDelete
  13. Revo Uninstaller 64bit searches for an application’s data on your hard drives and in the Windows registry and displays any files, folders, and registry keys found so that you can delete them.

    ReplyDelete
  14. 360 Total Security 10 Crack is a free antivirus program. Provides a solution for computer protection. This software was developed by “Qihoo 360”, a China-based internet protection company. It prevents viruses, trojans and spyware. Provides protection for Microsoft Windows. The program can also be run on Windows XP, Mac OS and Linux.
    360 Total Security 10 Crack
    VLC Media Player Crack
    Download Youtube Downloader with Serial Key
    EaseUS Data Recovery Crack Keygen License Code 2021

    ReplyDelete
  15. Tenorshare 4uKey Licensed Email and Registration Code Free List allows you to erase the iPhone without a password and as a new recovery. This is the simple registration code. when the iPhone password has been cleared successfully.

    You can set your iPhone as new, with Password, Contact, and Face ID settings. If you have iTunes backup, in the cloud before, you can recover your iPhone from backup, then you will be prompted to find the latest Apple OS firmware or you can click to download it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Windows 10 Activator Download Serial key It uses Windows 10 and combines some cool features of Windows 7 and Windows 8 that make it proud of other Microsoft operating systems. The high-quality Windows computer gives you the most innovative security effects and capabilities.

    The easiest way not to do this is to make the tool comfortable, but you can also perform your daily tasks in the most creative and efficient way. After a while, Windows 10 caught the attention of many people, IT professionals, business people, and employees related to specific areas.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This section gives a clear message to the young people.
    Blogging, here's how to really blog.
    idm crack
    sketchup pro crack
    hard disk sentinel crack
    teamviewer crack

    ReplyDelete
  18. Very nice post I found your blog by accident
    I want to say that I love to surf.
    Post your blog I will subscribe to your RSS feed after all.
    I hope you will write again soon!
    Very nice post I found your blog by accident
    I want to say that I love to surf.
    Post your blog I will subscribe to your RSS feed after all.
    I hope you will write again soon!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Is this a paid topic or do you change it yourself?
    However, stopping by with great quality writing, it's hard to see any good blog today.

    Axure RP Pro Crack

    ReplyDelete
  20. Burnaware Professional Crack is a powerful CD / DVD burner. It is also a great burning tool for users who need to speed up the burning process for all mass production discs. Burnaware Professional Crack lets you create and manage bootable CDs / DVDs. In addition, users can create ISO images and rewritable discs and multitask them. Burnaware Professional is an effective solution for burning CDs, DVDs and DVDs for customers who need maximum management of all aspects of the recording system and who use multiple burners for the mass production of multiple discs and the short arrival time. You can download from this link https://crackclick.com/burnaware-professional-crack/

    ReplyDelete